The actual conversation occurred in Holland, Ohio just outside Toledo (home to the world renown Rockin' Ron's Mobile DJ Service). And contrary to the sentiment from the McCain campaign, Barack Obama did not kick down the door of Joe Wurzelbacher (now Joe Plumber) and demonstrate his new tax plan by hanging him upside down, shaking him, and shouting, "It's called Socialism, bitches". No, instead the event was a little lower profile. Obama was making his way through a crowd, shaking hands, kissing babies, healing with his Christ like powers, when he was approached by Joe the Plumber, who I can only imagine was holding a plunger and wearing overalls. Let's see...
What!? What kind of plumber is this guy anyway?
A) No crack
B) No plunger
C) Did not start the conversation with, "Well see there's your problem right there..."
Aside from those obvious problems, this encounter is what you might call 'normal', especially for a political campaign. Joe asked Barack a question, and Barack answered his question. He didn't spew off talking points, he didn't jump in front of Greek columns and talk about the audacity of hope, he gave Joe a straight answer. Yes, your taxes may be higher, because I'm trying to help people who aren't financially where you are yet. I'm gonna try to save you money so you can grow your business, but I'm not sure if I can.
Afterwards the mind-numbing political spin descended on reality. All of the sudden, Joe became a battle cry for John McCain's campaign. McCain is fighting for the Joe Plumbers all over the US, and how dare Barack Obama invade his personal life and attack him all because he asked a simple question. Unfortunately that's not what happened and it's even more unfortunate that one of the most honest exchanges of this election season has been turned so incredibly ass-backwards.
However, I think there is something incredibly telling in that short conversation. Did you notice how instead of talking around the point, Barack told Mr. Plumber exactly what his tax policy set out to do? I'll paraphrase, he's doing this whole Robin Hood tax policy for the plumbers, and other working class Americans like Joe, that struggled for years to afford their own small business. Obama wants to put more money in the hands of those individuals so that they can save and reinvest in themselves to someday have a 250K+ business of their own. It is unfortunate that those making more, pay more in taxes to offset those tax cuts, but such is the nature of the beast.
Obama's tax policy puts money in the hands of working class Americans, that's where his faith in the American economy lies, and isn't that the heart of American conservatism? Faith in the individual over government? It just happens that Obama is using government as a facilitator to empower those individuals. It seems to me that the traditional conservative model of economics has not worked as advertised. When discussing 'spread the wealth' philosophies, conservatives are quick to point out that the top 5% income earners in America pay over half of all income tax, but scroll down in that article and you'll also discover the income gap between rich and poor in our country is one of the largest in the world. It's also important to realize that the top 1% of wealthy Americans control approximately 35% of the wealth, so the top 5% paying half of the income taxes may be seen more as a necessity rather than highway robbery.
My point is this: if we're going to talk about putting our faith in the American worker, the backbone of the economy, then why don't we give him a bit of a tax break and see what he does with the money. If he goes and blows it on Gobstoppers and comic books, then the rich can have it back. For now, I wanna see Obama pick Bill Gates up by the ankles and shake out my college loan payments!

